Except they're not.
While both teams have ended up in the same place in the standings at the end of one month of play, each team has taken a completely different path to get there. In all honesty, if we didn't already know the Sox by face, name, and number, we would be absolutely convinced that Version 2008 had undergone a complete overhaul in the offseason. It's a totally different team.
Take Manny Ramirez for example. In 24 April games in 2007, Manny hit an abysmal .202 which partly accounted for his equally abysmal .629 OPS. He hit only three home runs and struck out 15 times. He drove in only 13 runs. Flip the calendar, and you'll find a completely different story. In April of 2008, Manny has hit 141 points higher (.343) and has an OPS 405 points higher than last April's. He's hit twice as many home runs and driven in seven more runs. He's done this while actually walking less and striking out more.
But it's not just one player who exemplifies this polarity. It's apparent in the whole team. The 2008 Red Sox have taken a whole new direction than their predecessors of only a year ago. In 2007, the Red Sox hit just .262 as a team through April, yet scored 5.2 runs per game. This year's team has posted a .284 average through April, but has scored about a half run less per game. Home runs have also come less frequently for the '08 version of the Sox. Last season, the Sox hit more than one home run a game in April (1.125). This season, the Sox check in at under one home run per game (.821). The Sox, ever so walk-prone, drew 4.625 walks per game through the first month of last season. This season is naturally a different story; the Sox have drawn almost a full walk less per game (3.643) this April.
Just over two weeks ago, I described how the pitching staff has strayed a bit from the organizational philosophy this season by racking up high pitch counts, issuing a lot of walks, and failing to pitch deep into games. This assessment is still amazingly accurate. Last season, Sox pitching issued only 69 walks in 24 April games while allowing a baserunner less than 30% of the time. This is a markedly different performance than that portrayed so far by 2008's numbers. This April, the Red Sox pitching staff has racked up 121 walks and a .336 OBP against. They've surrendered 10 more home runs (28 to 18) and have posted an ERA well over a run higher (4.45 to 3.28). Granted, most of the blame can fall at the feet of the bullpen, which has been less than spectacular. The bullpen, through April in 2007, posted a 2.18 ERA, a 1.16 WHIP, and a 9.0 K/9. This season, not so much. The '08 bullpen has posted an ERA and WHIP far closer to the legal driving age at 5.25 and 1.58, respectively. The strikeout rate has actually remained relatively constant.
![]() |
| Manny is not being Manny! |
David Ortiz raked more than a farmer last April to the tune of a .297/.402/.615 line. He hit seven homers with 22 RBIs, 18 runs scored, 15 walks, and 18 strikeouts. This April, Big Papi wouldn't quite be considered a Bash Brother. While posting virtually identical RBI, walk, and strikeout totals, he's hit only four home runs with a brutal .172/.287/.313 line.
How about Dustin Pedroia, he of the horrific start last season? That horrific start was quantified by a wretched .182/.308/.236 line. He had just 10 hits all of last April, only three of which were extra-base hits. He had only two RBIs and five runs scored. It's amazing that he went on to win the Rookie of the Year and hit over .300. This April, Pedroia has looked more like the April version of Alex Rodriguez than the October version he looked like in April last year. He's off to a .313/.357/.435 start with 36 hits, 12 extra-base hits, and 14 runs scored.
On the offensive side, Coco Crisp and JD Drew have gotten off to unfamiliarly hot starts. And Mike Lowell, due in part to his injury, has struggled out of the gate.
Comparing the pitching staffs this early in the season may not be totally fair. After all, there's been about a 40% turnover in this April's starting rotation as compared to last April's rotation. And the bullpen has been turned over by about 50%. That being said, as you'd expect from the topic of this post, the 2008 numbers do not mirror those of a season ago. Josh Beckett was 5-0 with a 2.48 and 28 strikeouts through five April starts last season. This April, Beckett is 2-2 with a 4.10 ERA, but does have 29 strikeouts. Mike Timlin, in April '07, appeared in eight games and posted an ugly 5.87 ERA. Interestingly enough, he got worse this April. Far worse. In April '08, his ERA has almost tripled to 13.50 in nine games. And finally, Javier Lopez who put up a spotless ERA last April has compiled a 4.50 ERA this April.
The first month of 2008 has certainly been a different ride than that of 2007. If I had to give an answer as to how or why we've been able to play first place ball while taking a far different path than the team did last season, I'd say that it's got to be the steady offense and its utilization of Moneyball principles. In April of 2007, the offense put up .353/.426/.779 (OBP/SLG/OPS) line. This April, it's a frighteningly similar .356/.423/.779. Regardless, I don't care what the means are, as long as the same end is achieved in 2008 as it was in 2007, I will be a happy blogger.









